Silly Me
““Well, we’re all different. Why should a smoker pay more?””—
Rep. Pete Sessions (R-TX), when asked “Why should a woman pay more than a man [for health premiums]?” (via ohfortheloveofdog)
I guess I’ll have to remember the next time I’m born to select the y chromosome option. Silly me, making the choice to be a woman!
Why should I have to pay for contact lenses? I didn’t choose to have bad eyesight.
Why should I have to pay for restaurant food? I didn’t choose to be hungry.
Why should I have to pay my taxes? I didn’t choose to be born in this country.
Why should I have to buy health insurance under Obama’s plan? I didn’t choose Obama to be President.
Silly me. I’ve been paying for services based upon things like their market value.[1] This value is set by things like supply and demand. And these things are driven by things like cost and utility.
From now on, I’m not going to pay for things that I didn’t choose. (“Hey Mr. Umbrella man—hand one over. I didn’t choose for it to rain!”)
—
1. Or sometimes, because the government makes me buy it even if I don’t want it.
The reality is that there are cost differentials on a number of variables. It’s socially acceptable to pass some of those differentials on to consumers, but not others. You can’t charge someone more for health insurance because they’re a woman or because they’re gay. But you can charge smokers more.
Society has decided to make gay people and women protected classes. For all sorts of (mostly good) reasons. Society has decided to make the opposite decision about smokers for all sorts of (mostly good) reasons.
Deal with it.
Notes about this post from the Tumblr community:
-
dfdeshom liked this
-
iambal liked this
-
prettyyoungtext liked this
-
rosasparks liked this
-
randyhaddock liked this
-
un liked this
-
sds reblogged this from jeffmiller
-
zachrose liked this
-
tylerhwillis reblogged this from mikehudack and added:
basically boil down...choice in my book....man or woman,...
-
azspot liked this
-
pinkpolkadots liked this
-
robot-heart-politics reblogged this from jeffmiller and added:
do is automatically...higher insurance premium because you need glasses. And in fact,
-
krystalgomez reblogged this from winstonwolfe and added:
Agreed. And I’ve always wondered about the haircut thing. Isn’t there a way to achieve the stated goal more effectively?...
-
therealestsocksinthegame liked this
-
abcsoupdot liked this
-
mikehudack reblogged this from caterpillarcowboy and added:
This is a key example. African Americans...heart disease but are not, to my knowledge,...
-
mikehudack reblogged this from winstonwolfe and added:
I’m not a fan of the slippery slope argument. Jeff: what I’m saying is that certain risk premiums for protected classes...
-
aedison liked this
-
caterpillarcowboy reblogged this from winstonwolfe and added:
This doesn’t happen already? Aren’t African-Americans more at risk for heart disease? Don’t older people have higher...
-
wooliebear liked this
-
erikawithac liked this
-
jeffmiller reblogged this from robot-heart-politics and added:
But you agree, at least, that I shouldn’t have to pay for the glasses....But you must...
-
ronen liked this
-
slackmo liked this
-
winstonwolfe reblogged this from jeffmiller and added:
So will it be okay if the government decides to charge African-American men/women more than Caucasian men/women? What if...
-
aslowboattopurgatory liked this
-
ladykara liked this
-
jeffmiller reblogged this from mikehudack and added:
Mike … if women are being charged more for health insurance premiums, it isn’t because they are women. It’s because the...
-
thepoliticalpartygirl liked this
-
fredrik liked this
-
sailingonthesea liked this
-
hilker liked this
-
laurakelly00 reblogged this from robot-heart-politics and added:
your insurance premium,...
-
heroicdestinysquad liked this
-
robot-heart-politics reblogged this from jeffmiller and added:
You can always choose the less expensive option—glasses....You can always choose the less...
-
thedisgruntledgradstudent liked this
-
mikehudack reblogged this from jeffmiller and added:
The reality is that there are cost differentials on a number of variables. It’s socially acceptable to pass some of...
-
lenorebeadsman liked this
-
heroicdestinysquad reblogged this from robot-heart-politics
-
nogoodboyo liked this
-
jeffmiller reblogged this from robot-heart-politics and added:
Why should I have to pay for contact lenses? I didn’t choose to have bad eyesight. Why should I have to pay for...
-
simply-living liked this
-
thetrainback liked this
-
nerdgasms liked this
-
woosawoosa liked this
-
greaterthanlapsed reblogged this from robot-heart-politics
-
hurricane-k liked this
-
laurakelly00 reblogged this from robot-heart-politics
-
laurakelly00 liked this
-
thatsloverly reblogged this from robot-heart-politics
- Show more notes